My original aim with this blog was to write more about my experiences being diagnosed with Stargardts, however tied up with my worries about that is the big worry about reading ingredients labels due to my daughter having several life-threatening allergies. Yes, I wrote ‘life-threatening’, not feeling a bit off or poorly but she could die. The labelling laws are due to change here at the end of next year and as far as I am concerned, good or bad eyesight not withstanding, they are certainly due to change for the worse. My last post dealt with this subject and a number of other people are also blogging about it Yesnobananas has written some excellent posts, http://yesnobananas.wordpress.com/2013/09/11/update-allergy-labelling-laws/ and also http://yesnobananas.wordpress.com/2013/09/16/an-email-to-the-food-standards-agency/ and again http://yesnobananas.wordpress.com/2013/09/20/is-no-reason-good-reason-more-on-allergy-labelling/
I have sent 3 comments in as replies to the FSA blog. One of them seems to have vanished, it certainly never appeared on the blog. One is there and my third is below.
Comment on FSA response to concerns about new labelling rules:
I am sorry, you state that publishing the ‘advice’ a year before the new rules come into place is so that consumers have time to get used to them! Why should we have to get used to something that is a retrograde step? You have time, now the ramifications have been pointed out – change the rules. Surely that should be the point of publishing, so that if errors are discovered they can be rectified.
I remember the days before allergen warning boxes were used, we were dealing with intolerances not full blown danger of death allergic reactions then. I have lost count of the number of times over the past few years that I have said how much better life is with the allergen boxes. It really does sound to me that somebody somewhere has completely lost sight of the real goal here.
You state that having the ingredients in one place will make it easier if people visit other EU countries. This is patently untrue unless you are familiar with all the languages. Ingredients lists for countries other than the country of purchase are often even harder to read. At least with allergen boxes you have a head start on the common names of the allergens for that country.
Your reply still does nothing to alleviate any concerns just treats allergy consumers as if we do not know any better. When the consultations with Allergy UK and Anaphylaxis uk took place what form did they take? If there was a question such as. “Would you like to see all the allergen information in one place?’ Then I would expect the answer to be yes. And if a question was ‘Would you like to see allergens highlighted in the ingredients list?” Then again I would expect the answer to be yes. However if the question was ‘Would you prefer to have allergens highlighted in the ingredients list and the elimination ( no longer even voluntary inclusion) of allergen boxes?’ Then I would expect the answer to be NO!
You say that you hope to continue to engage with consumers, does this mean that you will actually listen to us or tell us that you- not dealing with life threatening allergies on a daily basis- know best? After all we must be too emotionally involved or stupid to understand the issues properly because that is how you are coming across at the moment.
The more I think about it the more I find it hard to understand why these new rules are supposed to be an improvement: warning boxes removed, no gluten warnings, allergens highlighted in different ways and no ‘one stop’ name for any particular allergen- you have to know all the variants. And if manufacturers want to help us by adding warning boxes they can’t! This seems to me to be the most stupid part of the legislation. One of the reasons for getting rid of allergy warning boxes is given as the fact that not all manufacturers use them and some will not want to take up the extra space they require. Yes, some products do not use them but why pander to the lowest common denominator. I am quite prepared to be convinced that the new system will be better but so far nothing the FSA have said comes anywhere near to reassuring me, let alone convincing me. As I have previously said I remember the days before the allergy warning boxes and I fear we are returning to them, in spite of allergies being on the rise.